(A) One day while Grace was in reading class, the teacher called on Billy to read a sentence from the board. He had been sick most of the winter and had missed a lot of school. Billy stood to read the sentence, but he didn’t know all the words. Since (a) she had been listening to the class, Grace read it for him. Billy sat down, redfaced and unhappy.
(B) After that incident, the teacher was invited to a church dinner which Grace’s mom attended, too. While talking with her, the teacher happened to remark, “I know Grace is bright, but I’m worried these days. She doesn’t recite or answer any question during class. I can’t understand it.” Mom couldn’t understand it either. She had heard Grace reading her book at home, and her brother drilled her on her sums until (b) she knew them well.
(C) Grace felt rather proud of herself for having known more than Billy did. (c) Her pride didn’t last long, however. Her brother, Justin, reported to Mom what had happened. He said, “Grace made Billy feel like a fool today.” Grace tossed her head defiantly. “Well, I did know the words, and Billy didn’t,” she said proudly. “Your brother is right, Grace,” said Mom. “You made Billy feel bad by reading for him. After this, you are not to speak up, even if (d) you do know the answer.” Grace nodded her head. She understood that if she knew something, she was to keep it to herself.
(D) Mom approached the subject at suppertime, asking, “Grace, can you read your lessons?” Grace said, “Sure, Mom. I can read the whole book!” Mom was puzzled. “Then why,” she asked, “does the teacher say you don’t recite in school?” Grace was surprised. “Why, Mom,” she answered, “you told me not to!” Mom exclaimed, “Why, Grace, I did no such thing!” “Yes, (e) you did,” Grace said. “You told me not to speak up, even when I knew the answer.” Mom remembered. The matter was soon straightened out, and Grace recited again during class.